Engagement Ring Retailer Reviews

In-depth reviews of a range of US diamond sellers

There’s many places you could buy a diamond ring, but many retailers unfortunately offer low quality stones at high prices.

Click through to read our reviews on a range of engagement retailers.

Each review looks at the retailers on four key points:

  • Diamond selection and quality
  • Setting selection
  • Service
  • Value for money
zales service
james allen logo

James Allen review

Probably the highest quality diamond imagery on the web, but how does the service stack up?

blue nile hompeage logo

Blue Nile Review

One of the original online diamond retailers. But are they any good?

Brilliant earth logo

Brilliant Earth Review

Positioned as the ethical choice, does their customer experience match their marketing?

helzberg homepage

Helzberg review

Helzberg is a storied name in the American retail industry – find out how they compare to others.

whiteflash homepage logo

Whiteflash review

See why this retailer is so well-regarded for their diamond quality and service.

Kay homepage

Kay Review

Probably the US’s largest diamond retailer, find out whether they might be a good fit for you.

ascot homepage

Ascot Review

Do they deliver on their promise of delivering a better diamond buying experience?

Brian Gavin Tile

Brian Gavin Review

Brian Gavin has a built a strong reputation for delivering only the highest cut quality.

zales homepage

Zales Review

One of the US’s largest chains of jewelers, find out whether size = quality.

robbins bros homepage

Robbins Bros. review

Robbins Bros. just celebrated their centenary – has all their practice paid off?

leibish tile

Leibish Review

Colored-diamond specialists who have the widest range of yellow diamonds anywhere.

rogers hollands

Rogers & Hollands

Established for over 100 years, how does Rogers & Hollands stack up today?

shane homepage

Shane Co. Review

A 4th generation family business, Shane Co. should have all the ingredients for great service.

jared homepage

Jared Review

Owned by the same company as Kay and Zales, learn how it compares to other retailers.

BC jewels tile

B2C Jewels Review

Value-focused retailer with a good selection of diamond settings and high quality stones.

diamonds direct homepage

Diamonds Direct

Positioned as cutting out the middle-man, see whether this is reflected in their service.