5 Carat Round Diamond Ring
Ultimate guide to buying a 5 carat round diamond
5 carat round diamonds are a beautiful choice – they sparkle the most out of any diamond shape and, if you prioritise cut quality, your ring will catch eyes from across any room!
Round brilliants are one of the most popular shapes for a 5 carat engagement ring, which means that there is a good supply of stones available and you should be able to find exactly what you are looking for.
It also means that finding the best 5 carat round diamond can mean reviewing and rejecting sub-par stones. That’s where this page will help.
There are many factors that affect price and value of a 5 carat round diamond.
While it is possible to buy from a large retailer like James Allen, it’s a better idea to work with a specialist in significantly-sized diamonds, who can guide you through the process and ensure you get the most beautiful diamond and pay a fair price.
Our recommendation is Alon at The Diamond Oak, a third generation diamond dealer who puts a huge emphasis on personalised service and finding the right stone for each person.
I recommend you read the testimonials here and then see whether you think that Alon could be a good fit for you.
5 carat round diamond price
As a broad range, the cost of a 5 carat round diamond can vary from $51,000 to $439,000.
To understand how much a 5 carat round cut diamond costs, we conducted research across three online diamond aggregation services which collectively have over 1,000,000 diamonds available to choose from, and then checked this against the most widely-accepted list of wholesale diamond prices.
$51,000 to $439,000 is a significant range, and the price you will pay will depend on the color, clarity and the ‘make’ if the stone ie. how well the diamond has been shaped.
With diamonds, you generally get what you pay for, so ‘cheap’ 5 carat round shaped diamonds will likely have a low-price for a reason – this may be significant inclusions (or ‘flaws’), or it may have poor proportions to reflect light and therefore not sparkle well.
But, when buying a diamond, there is always a balance that needs to be found between the 4Cs and the fifth C – cost. Where that balance lies for you is an individual choice, so it can be worth looking at a few options to where you are comfortable compromising, and where you aren’t.
How much do 5 carat round diamonds cost?
The table below will give you an idea of how color and clarity affect a 5 carat round diamond’s price:
If a price doesn’t appear, it means that no diamonds at that spec were available at the time this article was written.
It’s important to recognise that at this carat weight, there can be considerable differences between individual stones with similar specs on paper, so these are very much just a guide.
Factors such as availability at the time you are looking, and then specific of the individual diamond (e.g. the cut quality) will affect the price of any individual stone. However, the prices quoted should be a good guide to understand the relative pricing of different combinations of color and clarity for 5 carat round brilliant diamonds.
5 carat round diamond size
Round diamonds are one of the ‘spreadiest’ shapes of any diamond, which means that for a given carat weight, they appear larger than other shapes.
A typical 5 carat round diamond may be around 11.11mm × 11.11mm × 6.7mm.
Here’s how it looks compared to a 4 carat and a 6 carat:
One important thing to understand when you are looking at 5 carat round diamonds is that carat weight is a measure of weight rather than size.
Carat weight is therefore spread out throughout the volume of the stone ie. length, width and depth.
Round diamonds ‘face up’ smaller than shallower, elongated shapes like an oval diamond ring at 5 carats or a 5 carat emerald cut diamond ring, but larger than most squarer shapes like a cushion cut diamond at 5 carats.
Watch out: poorly proportioned diamonds
One thing to watch out for with higher carat weight round brilliant diamonds is that they may have been cut with a poor proportions, just to make it to 5 carats in weight.
This can result in diamonds that are overly-shallow or too tall, which will mean that their shape isn’t optimised to reflect light correctly.
A diamond that doesn’t reflect light well is one that looks dull and lifeless – definitely something to avoid.
It’s therefore a good idea to continue to prioritise ‘cut’ quality in 5 carat diamonds, just as you would for a lighter diamond.
5 carat round diamond color
Higher carat weight diamonds tend to show up color more easily than smaller stones, especially in the corners where they sparkle less.
If you want to ensure your diamond doesn’t have a yellow tint, it’s important to try and keep the color as high up the scale as possible.
On the other side of the equation is the effect color has on price.
In most shapes, the price difference between an H color, I color and J color diamond can be significant,
With a 5 carat round brilliant diamond, the color grade you choose can be dependant on the color of the ring setting you are going to pair the diamond with. If you are choosing a white colored setting (platinum or white gold), then I color delivers a good balance of white appearance and value.
However, if you are choosing a yellow gold setting, then you can reduce the color of your diamond to K without it looking yellow, as it will still look white compared to the warm tones of the setting.
5 carat round diamond clarity
Clarity is a measure of the presence of inclusions (or flaws) within a diamond.
The clarity scale runs:
Round diamonds are a brilliant cut, which means that they are optimised to reflect light back from the bottom of the stone in the form of brilliant sparkle. This can mean that inclusions can be difficult to see under the facets, which is a good thing!
A good starting point for 5 carat round diamond clarity is SI1:
However, depending on the diamonds that are available at the time you are looking, you may need to increase this to VS2, or even higher, to ensure that the diamond is ‘eye clean’ and no flaws can be seen.
Pictures of 5 carat round diamond rings on the hand
Higher carat weight rings mean that additional considerations can be needed to be taken into account, depending on the ring setting style chosen.
These images of 5 carat round diamond rings on the finger will show you how big your ring could actually look.
5 carat round diamond solitaire settings
Solitaire settings are a great match for round brilliant diamonds – the simple style is a great pairing with the elegance of the diamond.
A major trend with settings is super slim and petite bands and prongs, which are effective in making the stone itself look larger.
While these can look great, some care does need to be taken with higher carat weights, as an extremely narrow band may not be wide enough to support the stone. It may twist on the finger and become uncomfortable.
If you’re choosing a solitaire setting to match a 5 carat round diamond, I recommend you choose a band of at least 2.5mm width.
5 carat round diamond pavé ring
When choosing a pavé or channel setting, there is a big decision to make.
Either can be a great option, but one thing to consider is the color of the side stones.
Small, brilliant cut stones can appear whiter than larger diamonds, which means that even if you do match the color by the color grade, they still may appear whiter.
In cases like these, especially if you are going a little lower on the color on your center stone, like in the image above, it can be a good idea to work with an expert to ensure that the side stones complement the center stone.
5 carat round diamond three stone ring
Three stone round brilliant rings look great when paired with almost any other shape as the side stones.
Tapered side stones can work particularly well because the side stones make the transition from the long broad side of the diamond to the narrow band more gentle and more elegant.
5 carat round diamond halo ring
At 5 carats, some may feel that a halo is unnecessary to increase the size and impressiveness of the ring.
However, if you do choose a halo ensuring the side stones are a good match for the center stone is essential, due to their proximity.
Even more so than with a pave or channel setting, working with someone who can color-match the side stones to the center stone is the best way to ensure that they complement each other well.
Best Place To Buy a 5 Carat Round Diamond Ring
For smaller carat weights, my recommended retailer is frequently James Allen, which offers a huge selection of stones and can be a good option if you are confident in making a decision yourself.
However, buying a diamond of this size diamond is very different to buying a smaller stone – both in the expense involved and in the potential for pitfalls.
If you feel that you would like some assistance with the purchase (and at this carat weight, that can be a good idea), my recommendation is Alon Mor at The Diamond Oak.
I like this review of his service – it’s worth a read to understand just how special buying a diamond can be.
If you’d like to feel as special as the person in this review, I’d recommend getting in touch with Alon. Let him know you heard of him through Ringspo and he will go above and beyond to make the experience even more special.
Or, if you’d like to send through a direct enquiry with what you’re looking for, just enter your details in the form below: