Best Way To Sell Inherited Jewelry: Find Out Here:

Inherited jewelry often represents more than just material value – it carries memories and family history.

But what if you decide to sell?

Whether it’s a diamond ring passed down through generations or a gold necklace with sentimental value, selling these items can be a complex process. 

In this guide, we’ll provide practical insights into selling inherited jewelry, focusing on how to assess its worth and find the best selling options.

best way to sell inherited jewelry

The significance of inherited jewelry goes beyond its monetary value – it’s a tangible connection to family history and memories – so making a decision on why and where to sell it can involve more than just where you can get the most money for it.

Why Sell Your Inherited Jewelry?

There are various reasons why someone might choose to sell your inherited jewelry. For some, the pieces may not align with their personal style or taste. Others may see an opportunity to convert these valuable assets into funds for other important life goals, such as buying a home or funding education.

Selling inherited jewelry is not a decision to be taken lightly. It requires careful consideration of both the emotional and practical aspects. In the following sections, we’ll explore the best ways to sell inherited jewelry, ensuring you get the most value and make the process as smooth as possible.

Preparing to Sell Your Inherited Jewelry

There are several steps to undertake when selling estate jewelry, and trying to shortcut the process, googling ‘where to sell inherited jewelry near me‘ or similar means that you’re likely to receive significantly less than you likely hope.

Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you prepare for selling your inherited jewelry.

Appraisal and Knowing Your Jewelry’s Value

Understanding the true value of your inherited jewelry is crucial before putting it on the market. An appraisal will provide you with an accurate assessment of what your jewelry is worth, considering factors like age, rarity, materials, and craftsmanship.

sapphire ring appraisal

An appraisal is not just about determining the monetary value; it’s about understanding the unique characteristics that make your piece special. Knowing what your jewelry is worth can guide your pricing strategy and ensure you don’t undersell a valuable item.

To appraise your jewelry, seek a certified appraiser who specializes in the type of jewelry you have. They will examine the piece, possibly using specialized tools, and provide a detailed report. It can also be a good idea to obtain an appraisal at more than one place to get a well-rounded opinion.

Insuring Your Jewelry

It can be an easy one to miss, but insuring your inherited jewelry will provide protection against loss, theft, or damage during the selling process. A small expense can provide peace of mind, especially if the jewelry is being handled by other people during the sales process.

You should be able to add jewelry to your home or renter’s insurance or alternatively you can consider specialized jewelry insurance providers who offer tailored coverage, which may be more flexible if you are only insuring for a short period of time.

Tips for Selling Your Inherited Jewelry

Selling inherited jewelry requires a thoughtful approach. Here are some expert tips for selling that can help you fetch the best price:

  • Research the History: A well-told story about the piece can add value and interest. Was it worn on a special occasion? Does it represent a specific era or style?
  • Explore Niche Communities: Online forums or social media groups focusing on specific types of jewelry or historical periods can be valuable platforms for understanding whether your jewelry is merely ‘estate’ jewelry or whethert it can be classified as vintage or even antique.
  • Time the Sale: Consider selling the jewelry to coincide with specific seasons, holidays, or themes that align with the piece.
  • Offer Personalized Services: If selling through a personal online store, consider offering services like custom resizing, engraving, or gift wrapping.
  • Collaborate With Influencers: Consider working with jewelry influencers or bloggers to showcase the piece, especially if it’s unique or has a compelling story.

Best Places to Sell Inherited Jewelry

When it comes to selling inherited jewelry, choosing the right platform is crucial.

Each option has its unique advantages and potential drawbacks.

And while there’s no place that is the best for absolutely everyone, there are definitely places that make it significantly more likely that you will receive the best price for your inherited jewelry.

Selling Through a Jeweler

A great option for selling your inherited jewelry is through a jeweler. Here’s a look at the pros and cons:


  • Expertise: A professional jeweler can accurately assess the value of your piece.
  • Trust: Established jewelers often have a reputation for fair dealing.
  • Convenience: Many jewelers offer immediate payment.


  • Price: You may not get the highest price as jewelers often resell the pieces.
  • Limited Audience: Your piece won’t reach a broader market.

Selling at Auction

Auctions can be an exciting way to sell inherited jewelry, especially unique or high-value pieces.

The Auction Process:

  • Select an Auction House: Choose a reputable auction house that specializes in jewelry.
  • Set a Reserve Price: Determine a minimum price with the help of experts.
  • Promote and Auction: The auction house will market your piece and conduct the auction.

Online Marketplaces

Online marketplaces have become increasingly popular for selling jewelry, offering a wide reach and various platforms tailored to different types of jewelry. Here’s a closer look at some of the prominent online platforms and essential tips if you want to sell your jewelry online:

Alloy: Specializing in gold jewelry, Alloy offers a platform for those looking to sell gold pieces, whether antique or contemporary. They provide secure transactions and may even offer appraisal services to ensure you understand the value of your gold jewelry.

Alloy Homepage

Worthy: Ideal for those with a large batch of jewelry to sell, Worthy conducts auctions and offers GIA-certified appraisals. Their platform is designed to reach a network of professional buyers, ensuring competitive bids for your collection.

sell diamond earrings to worthy

The Diamond Oak: A go-to for significant diamonds and designer jewelry, The Diamond Oak focuses on high-end pieces. They offer personalized consultations, professional photography, and marketing to showcase your jewelry to a discerning audience.

sell engagement ring diamond oak

Tips for Selling Inherited Jewelry Online:

  • Choose Reputable Platforms: Look for sites that offer authentication and secure transactions. Platforms that provide GIA certification or other trust-building measures can add credibility to your listing.
  • Provide Accurate Descriptions: Include clear photos from various angles and detailed information about the piece, such as the type of metal, gemstone details, historical significance, and any unique features.
  • Consider the Target Audience: Tailor your listing to appeal to the specific audience interested in your type of jewelry. For example, highlight the craftsmanship of antique pieces or the purity of gold items.
  • Set a Fair Price: Research similar items online to gauge a fair price for your jewelry. Consider offering a “Buy It Now” option or allowing for negotiation.
  • Offer Secure Payment Options: Utilize secure payment methods and consider offering a return policy to build trust with potential buyers.
  • Provide Excellent Customer Service: Respond promptly to inquiries, provide additional information if requested, and keep the buyer informed throughout the transaction process.
  • Consider Shipping and Packaging: Offer secure and insured shipping, and consider providing attractive packaging, especially if selling a high-value item.

Pros of Selling Inherited Jewelry Online:

  • Wider Audience: Online platforms can reach a global audience, potentially attracting more buyers interested in your specific piece of jewelry.
  • Convenience: You can list the jewelry from the comfort of your home, providing details and images that highlight its features.
  • Specialized Platforms: There are online marketplaces specifically tailored for selling jewelry, such as Alloy for gold jewelry or The Diamond Oak for significant diamonds and designer pieces. These platforms may offer authentication and secure transactions.
  • Control Over Pricing: You can set your price, negotiate with buyers, and potentially get a better deal than selling through traditional methods.
  • Potential for Storytelling: Online listings allow for detailed descriptions and storytelling, which can add value and interest to unique or antique pieces.

Cons of Selling Inherited Jewelry Online:

  • Security Concerns: If not using a reputable platform, there might be risks related to fraud or scams.
  • Competition: The online marketplace can be saturated, and standing out among numerous listings might be challenging.
  • Fees and Commissions: Some online platforms may charge listing fees or take a percentage of the sale.
  • Time-Consuming: Managing online listings, communicating with potential buyers, and handling shipping can be time-consuming.
  • Lack of Personal Interaction: Selling online means you may not have the opportunity to interact with buyers in person, which can make building trust more challenging.
  • Potential Need for Appraisal: Buyers may demand an appraisal or certification, such as GIA certification, which can be an additional step in the selling process.

Selling Through a Pawn Shop

Pawn shops can be a quick way to sell. There’s minimal paperwork involved and there’s an immediate cash offer. The downsides are that it often pays less than market value, especially if the owner doesn’t have specialized knowledge in fine jewelry.

Selling Through a Consignment Shop

Consignment shops offer a more personalized approach to selling jewelry.

You and the shop agree on a price, the shop displays your piece to potential buyers, and it takes a commission upon sale.


  • Personalized Service: Tailored marketing and sales approach.
  • Potential for Higher Price: Can reach targeted customers.


  • Time-Consuming: May take longer to sell.
  • Commission Fees: The shop takes a percentage of the sale.

Understanding the Value of Different Jewelry Types

Different types of jewelry have varying values based on their materials, craftsmanship, rarity, and demand. Here’s a closer look at some common types:

Diamond Jewelry: Diamonds are prized for their brilliance, durability, and rarity. The value of diamond jewelry depends on the 4Cs: Carat, Cut, Color, and Clarity. Larger diamonds with high-quality cuts, minimal color, and few inclusions are generally more valuable. Special cuts or rare diamond colors can also increase the value. Remember, not all diamonds are created equal, and understanding the specific characteristics of your diamond can help you set the right price.

Gold Jewelry: Gold’s timeless appeal and intrinsic value make gold jewelry a sought-after commodity. The value depends on the purity (karat), weight, and design. Unique or designer pieces may fetch higher prices.

Platinum and Vintage Jewelry: Platinum jewelry is valued for its durability and rarity, often commanding higher prices than gold. Vintage jewelry, on the other hand, may have value based on its historical significance, craftsmanship, or connection to a specific era or designer.

Negotiating the Best Price

Once you understand the value of your inherited jewelry, the next step is negotiating to get the best price. Here are some tips to help you succeed:

  • Know Your Worth: Have a clear understanding of the value of your piece, based on appraisals or research. Don’t be afraid to walk away from an offer that doesn’t meet your expectations.
  • Be Transparent: Provide all relevant information, including any appraisals, certifications, or known history of the piece.
  • Consider Multiple Offers: If possible, obtain offers from multiple buyers to gauge the market and negotiate effectively.
  • Build Rapport: Approach negotiations with professionalism and courtesy. Building a positive relationship with the buyer can lead to a more favorable outcome.
  • Use Timing to Your Advantage: Consider market trends, seasons, or specific events that may increase demand for your type of jewelry.

Making the Right Choice When Selling Inherited Jewelry

Selling inherited jewelry is a personal and often complex journey. From understanding the value of different types of jewelry to exploring various selling platforms and negotiating the best price, there are many factors to consider.

Choosing the best option to sell your jewelry depends on your specific needs, the type of jewelry, and your goals for the sale. 

Here’s a recap and some final thoughts to guide you in making the right choice.

Recap of Selling Options

The journey of selling inherited jewelry offers various selling options, each with its unique advantages and potential challenges:

  • Jewelers: Expertise and trust but may not offer the highest price.
  • Auctions: Exciting and potentially lucrative but requires an understanding of the auction process.
  • Online Marketplaces: Wide reach and specialized platforms but demands careful listing and security measures.
  • Pawn Shops: Quick and simple but often at a lower value.
  • Consignment Shops: Personalized service and potential for higher price but may be time-consuming.

Final Thoughts and Actionable Takeaways

  • Educate Yourself: Understand the value of your jewelry, whether it’s diamond, gold, platinum, or vintage. Seek professional appraisals if needed.
  • Explore Your Options: Consider various platforms, from traditional jewelers to online marketplaces, and weigh the pros and cons.
  • Negotiate With Confidence: Know your worth and be prepared to negotiate to get the best price.
  • Understand the tax implications of selling estate jewelry: depending no where, you live, you may need to pay inheritance tax.
  • Make an Informed Decision: Reflect on your goals, the significance of the piece, and choose the option that aligns with your needs.

1.2 Carats+, Designer Engagement Rings
Diamond Oak
Best for big batches
Best for Gold & Precious Metals
Buyer name
Buyer name
Diamond Oak
Customer Review Scores
Customer Review Scores
4.9 from 67 reviews on Google reviews
4.7 from 2,473 reviews on Trustpilot
4.7 from 29 reviews on Trustpilot
Can send payment the day after sale price is agreed
Typically takes 2 weeks for auction to run
Can send payment the day after sale price is agreed
Free, trackable shipping
Free, trackable shipping
Free, trackable shipping
Up to $100,000
Up to $100,000
$5,000 standard, but can be increased to $100,000
Biggest benefit
Biggest benefit
Highest price paid for larger diamonds
Possibility of highest price due to largest number of potential buyers
Highest price for precious metals